Vital Football

Latest Walsall FC News

Dean Smith, should he stay or should he go?

Dean Smith, should he stay or should he go?

February 2012, and a season that began all so promisingly, with an opening day home victory against Leyton Orient, is well and truly on a downward spiral.

Some may say it wasn`t expected this season, some may say it was predictable, with or without the gift of hindsight.

Whichever way you choose to look at it, Walsall FC are heading for a relegation dogfight again, granted we are in a slightly better position than last season, but let`s face it not much.

So this then begs the unavoidable question, Do we have the correct man in the hotseat?

Dean Smith, a man with no managerial experience, yet a man who managed to guide the club back from no man`s land at Christmas 2010, to a final day survival by a singular point.

Managerial genius? Or just plain beginners luck?

Well the heroics performed by Smith last season to keep us in this league, led to him being affectionately nicknamed 'Ginger Mourinho`, and yet we find ourselves heading towards a similar situation this season with him at the helm.

We have the obvious arguments of requiring more backing from the financial hierarchy, and not being able to attract a decent caliber of players to the squad, but look at some of the players that were gotten rid of.

I`m sure we would all agree that we would kill at this moment for Matt Richards, Julian Gray etc back in the squad, in their places we got the inconsistent Adam Chambers, and the already departed Claude Gnakpa.

This is Dean`s team and at times he does make himself look quite inept, both tactically and otherwise.

-MK Dons at home and we go down to ten men losing Jimmy Walker, only to find out that our second choice David Grof isn`t on the bench so right back Lee Beevers pulls on the gloves.

-Does anyone actually know where Richard Taundry plays? Or is he just there as a stopgap for any positions unfilled?

-Ryan Jarvis (need any explanation?)

Granted he hasn`t been all bad, home win at an albeit struggling Preston side, home draw against table topping Charlton, away draw against Huddersfield, and who could forget the boxing day victory over Sheffield Wednesday?

The stats though, do to some extent speak for themselves! Four wins in 28 games, which as it stands leaves us only out of the relegation places on goal difference, is not really where the fans or Dean himself undoubtedly envisioned us at the start of the season.

Smith appears afraid of change, the same lineup seems to greet us at kick off every game, youngster Jamie Paterson has done brilliantly to push himself into the squad this season and deservedly so, but what else?

George Bowerman, doesn`t get as much of a chance as he could, and quite frankly where is Will Grigg?

Grigg started the season so well, touched a dip in form and hasn`t been seen since? If a slight dip in form is enough to expel a player from the team for such a long time under Smith then surely half the squad should be out at the moment?

I do believe that we need some fresh blood in the hot seat, and yes I`m aware that whoever the new blood is may face similar problems with lack of budget/backing etc.

Surely though, there is someone out there with more imagination, ambition and at times plain tactical awareness!

Vital Walsall on: facebook



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Lee Hale
Date:Friday February 3 2012
Time: 5:36PM

Login to post a comment

Recent Walsall Articles

Forde Closing In On Rotherham Move

Winger Anthony Forde set to become Rotherhams first signing of the summer.

Walsall Sign Southampton Starlet On Loan

Walsall sign highly rated Southampton centre back on loan until January.

Are Players Set For A Football Exit?

With the country narrowly voting to leave the European Union in Thursday's Referendum, there are certainly plenty of real questions that have to be addressed in terms...

Walsall Reject Rotherham Bid For Tom Bradshaw

Walsall reject bid of £250k from Rotherham for striker Tom Bradshaw

Archived Vital Saddlers Articles

Vital Saddlers articles from

Site Journalists

Kev
Editor email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Who Will Win League 1 Play-Offs?
Suggested By: Vital Kev
Walsall29%
Barnsley55%
Millwall14%
Bradford2%

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Wigan 46 24 15 7 87 37
P Burton 46 25 10 11 85 20
3 Walsall 46 24 12 10 84 22
4 Millwall 46 24 9 13 81 24
5 Bradford 46 23 11 12 80 15
6 Barnsley 46 22 8 16 74 16
7 Scunthorpe 46 21 11 14 74 13
8 Coventry 46 19 12 15 69 18
9 Gillingham 46 19 12 15 69 15
10 Rochdale 46 19 12 15 69 7
11 Sheff Utd 46 18 12 16 66 5
12 Port Vale 46 18 11 17 65 -2
13 Peterborough 46 19 6 21 63 9
14 Bury 46 16 12 18 60 -17
15 Southend 46 16 11 19 59 -6
16 Swindon 46 16 11 19 59 -7
17 Oldham 46 12 18 16 54 -14
18 Chesterfield 46 15 8 23 53 -12
19 Fleetwood 46 12 15 19 51 -4
20 Shrewsbury 46 13 11 22 50 -21
R Doncaster 46 11 13 22 46 -16
R Blackpool 46 12 10 24 46 -23
R Colchester 46 9 13 24 40 -42
R Crewe 46 7 13 26 34 -37
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Walsall Results (view all)